The hidden crisis in the gold business

by Michael J. Kosares

Barrick CEO Jamie Sokalsky has some things to say about the gold mining business that will come as a revelation to many gold owners. In a speech at the London Bullion Market Association’s conference in Hong Kong last November, Sokalsky wades into a largely hidden crisis in the gold business — static mine production that has not responded positively to the rising prices over the last several years, and is unlikely to ramp up even if prices go higher from here.

“There are very few mega-sized gold mines currently in production in the world,” said Sokalsky. “In terms of a cross-section of total gold mines by size, there are about 400 gold mines producing. Only 156 of these, or about 40%, produce over 100,000 ounces per year. . .Twenty-one mines produce over 500,000 ounces per year. . .Only six mines produce over 1 million ounces. . .It is also interesting to note that although there have been some gold discoveries, none can be described as a super giant — that 20-million-plus ounce deposit. They are harder to find and that is directly impacting production growth because those super-giant discoveries are really the ones that can have a material impact on supply.”

world gold production

Mine supply, according to the U.S. Geological Survey, is pretty much unchanged over the past 12 years — from 2560 metric tonnes in 2001 to 2700 metric tonnes in 2012. There was a dip in 2008 to 2280 metric tonnes.

Parenthetically, Barrick got some bad news in late April, when its Pascua Lama project — a 17.9 million ounce deposit (a near “giant” in Sokalsky terms) that straddles the Chile-Argentina border — was ordered closed by Chilean courts for environmental reasons. The trouble came after Sokalsky’s speech to the LBMA, so the outlook for global gold production is even tighter now than it was then. Work continues on the Argentina side, but Barrick says it might be forced to suspend spending on the mine if the regulatory issues “remain unclear,” according to a Reuters report.

Though there is always a possibility that the court decision might be reversed, Barrick’s problems at the Chile-Argentina border underscore the high risks in the mining business as pointed out by Sokalsky in his speech. Even strategically important mega-projects like the Pascua Lama can be derailed unexpectedly by exogenous events.

When you weigh the static global gold production against the growing global demand, you get a sense that something has to give somewhere. The supply fundamentals are one often overlooked by gold advocates who tend to concentrate on the monetary reasons for gold ownership. Sooner or later though, the tension between supply and demand will assert itself.

Sokalsky ends his speech with this:

“This industry is like a supertanker. It takes a long time to stop or change directions. You cannot turn on a dime. Most projects that are built right now, or are in advanced construction, will not be affected. However, the outlook for growth in supply in a few years looks more and more under threat. Thus, the supply of gold is likely to be lower going forward. We are not going to see huge growth, even if the gold price goes up considerably.”

It sounds like he was blind-sided by the Chilean court decision. The Pascua Lama was in “advanced construction” at the time of the closure. Barrick had spent “up to $8.5 billion” on the project, according to that same Reuters report. Creamer Media’s Mining Weekly reports that Barrick has made reactivating the project its number one priority, but that “many experts say the unpopular project faces an uphill battle.”

Link to Sokalsky speech


If you would like to broaden your view of gold market, we invite you to sign-up for our regular newsletter and receive quality commentary like what you are now reading. It’s free of charge and comes by e-mail. You can opt out at any time.

In addition, we invite you to bookmark this page for up to the minute news and opinion of interest to the gold owner.

News, Commentary & Analysis is edited by Michael J. Kosares, the founder of USAGOLD and the author of “The ABCs of Gold Investing: How To Protect and Build Your Wealth With Gold”, the widely read guideline to gold ownership.

This is an update of a post that first appeared on this page May 7, 2013.

This entry was posted in Today's top gold news and opinion. Bookmark the permalink.

Comments are closed.